Comments on “No cosmic justice”

Comments

In resonance

Branka's picture

Hello David,

I found your site accidentally. Even though I am not familiar with ARO , seems contemplating I've "caught up" so much of the same teaching. I do not believe in justice, considering humans as 90% (at least) robots. IF I AM RULED BY THE BELIEFS, DISBELIEFS AND WORLDLY SAYINGS - then WHO AM I AND HOW CAN I BE RESPONSIBLE?

I am pretty sure we were originated by a dangerously sick (deeply schizophrenic) intelligence, who can't be better to humans than to ITSELF (OK, Himself/Herself). If my native could be English, I'd probably be braver to share some of my experiences with something what considers itself a GALACTIC ARBITRATION (seems we are approaching change of some of the basic laws). Being "subjected" to that ARBITRATION , OMG!!!!!!!!!!! I have learned enough to CONSIDER MYSELF A GIANT for still loving life :)))).

Also I MORE THAN AGREE WITH YOU : NO HOLINESS - VASTNESS!

Thanks for sharing those beautiful things. You made my day (and more :)).

Branka Babic, Belgrade, Serbia (former Yugoslavia)

Orthodoxy & Temperaments

Sabio's picture

(1) Controversy additions
You should add the below to your list on Dzogchen controversies.

Dzogchen explicitly rejects the Law of Karma [not "orthodox" Buddhism].

(2) Heart Sutra Orthodoxy
Isn't the heart Sutra considered a typical Mahayana text and would not be embraced by some Theravada groups who would also not agree with its implications?

(3) Atheism
Interesting that you said you have been a long-term atheist. I have not. But ironically, opposed to you, cosmic justice was what took me out of Christianity. I guess I was always a mystic Christian only to discover that other Christians were into it for the rationality, the certainty and the morality -- none of which drew me. It just goes to show the varieties of temperaments. Thus my Atheist temperament is different from many atheists -- thus I started my site. Seeing how our temperaments often create our philosophies is the first step toward wisdom (IMHO), the second may be seeing the emptiness of our own temperaments.

1-2-3

David Chapman's picture

(1) Done, thanks!

(2) I don't know enough about Theravada to say. I think the Pali scriptures have substantially equivalent statements about certainty, eternity, and so forth, although expressed in slightly different terms.

(3) I think your point about temperaments is a very good one.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. If you have a Gravatar account, used to display your avatar.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <i> <em> <strong> <blockquote> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Each email address will be obfuscated in a human readable fashion or (if JavaScript is enabled) replaced with a spamproof clickable link.

More information about formatting options